Choose a video model by the shot you need to deliver, then judge the actual output. Model names, demo reels and subscription prices do not establish which provider will work for your character, motion or production budget.
Availability correction, 8 October 2026: OpenAI’s Sora 2 announcement states that the Sora product has been unavailable since 26 April 2026. Our earlier recommendation to subscribe to Sora was outdated. It has been removed from the active workflow. The original route is retained so existing links continue to reach the correction.
Evidence correction: the earlier page also quoted model-quality scores and per-second costs without linked benchmark records. Those figures have been removed. This is a production evaluation checklist, not a current measured ranking.
Choose the shot before the provider
Write a short brief with subject, action, camera, duration, aspect ratio and the visual references you have permission to use. Decide which features are requirements: native audio, image-to-video, a stable character, a particular resolution, or an export without a watermark.
Investigate current availability and plan terms for candidates such as Google Veo, Kling and Hailuo through their tool profiles and official product documentation. The versions and region access may differ between an API and a consumer app. No provider is declared a universal winner here.
A small shot test
- Character close-up: expression changes while face, clothing and framing remain stable.
- Interaction: a character picks up or sets down an object.
- Camera move: a restrained push or pan with a coherent background.
- Continuity: two adjacent shots using the same approved references.
- Audio, if required: speech and ambient sound with the intended delivery format.
Use the same brief and references on each candidate, then record settings, generated attempts and rejected takes. Inspect the beginning, middle and end of every clip. Check hands, object contact, changing backgrounds, text and transitions; do not hide failures by showing only the best frame.
Budget for usable seconds
Count the cost of all attempts needed to obtain an approved shot. Add subscriptions, generation credits, upscaling, voice, music, editing and your time. A low advertised generation rate can be expensive if most outputs need replacement. Check current plan terms and licensing before paying or publishing.
Set a retry limit before generation. If a shot continues to fail, simplify its action, shorten it, use a static composition or build it in a conventional animation workflow. Buying another model is not always the best next step.
Keep the edit in charge
Create a storyboard and rough animatic first. Generate only the shots the edit needs. Keep reference files and prompts with the accepted outputs so a later change is easier to reproduce. Use a consistent finishing pass, and check audio, captions, aspect ratio and mobile legibility in the final export.
For a short character piece, the stylised animation recipe provides a staged workflow and explicitly labels its assumptions. It does not establish a quality percentage or a guaranteed film budget.
What evidence would support a recommendation?
A useful published comparison includes the prompts, references, current model versions, plan, number of attempts, full clips and evaluation criteria. It should disclose failures and distinguish a creative preference from an objective requirement. We have not published that benchmark for these candidates.
Share a correction with a primary source if a feature or availability changes. For a current shortlist, use the catalogue’s evidence labels and then run the shot test against your own brief.
