Two newsletter platforms for creators. One gives you growth tools, the other gives you a built-in audience. Here's when each wins.
If you're treating your newsletter as a business, Beehiiv's growth tools, referral programs, ad network, and 0% revenue cut make it the clear choice. Substack is great for writers who want simplicity and a built-in discovery network.
Newsletter platform built for growth and monetization
Simple publishing platform with built-in reader network
| Feature | Beehiiv | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| Referral Program | Built-in referral system with rewards | No native referral tools |
| A/B Testing | Subject lines, content, send times | Not available |
| Audience Segmentation | Advanced segments and automations | Basic, free vs paid only |
| Ad Network | Beehiiv Ad Network, built-in | No ad monetization |
| Discovery Network | Beehiiv Boosts (paid recommendations) | Substack Network, strong organic discovery |
| Custom Domains | Yes, all plans | Yes, on paid plans |
| Revenue Cut | 0% platform fee | 10% of paid subscription revenue |
| Website Builder | Custom website with landing pages | Basic publication page |
| Analytics | Advanced, 3D analytics, UTM tracking | Basic open/click rates |
| Writing Experience | Clean editor with blocks | Distraction-free, minimal editor |
For creators serious about growing a newsletter business, Beehiiv is the clear winner. The referral system alone can 10x your organic growth, and keeping 100% of your revenue (vs losing 10% to Substack) adds up fast. Substack is still excellent if you're a writer who values simplicity and wants to tap into their discovery network, but the moment you start thinking about scale, Beehiiv's tools are in a different league.
For growth-focused creators, yes. Beehiiv offers referral programs, audience segmentation, A/B testing, and a built-in ad network, tools Substack simply doesn't have. However, Substack has a stronger built-in discovery network and a simpler, more writer-friendly experience.
Yes. Substack takes 10% of all paid subscription revenue, plus Stripe processing fees (~3%). Beehiiv charges 0% on its paid plans, you only pay your monthly platform fee and Stripe fees. At scale, this difference is significant.
Yes. Beehiiv has a one-click Substack importer that brings over your subscribers, posts, and metadata. The migration is straightforward and typically takes minutes. Many large newsletters have successfully migrated.
Yes. Beehiiv's Launch plan is free for up to 2,500 subscribers and includes unlimited sends, a custom website, and basic analytics. It's a solid way to start without any upfront investment. Paid plans unlock growth tools and advanced features.
Beehiiv, by far. It offers multiple monetization paths: paid subscriptions (0% platform cut), a built-in ad network, Boosts (get paid to recommend other newsletters), and premium content gating. Substack only offers paid subscriptions with a 10% cut.
Tell us what you are building and we will pick the right tool for you. Or if you are ready to switch, we can help you move without breaking things.
Free. No signup required.
Want someone to choose for you?
Get a Decision Memo (£29) →Personalised recommendation with rationale, based on your use case.
